US Soccer Players

The official site of the USMNT Soccer Players with soccer news, schedule, statistics, players, interviews, and exclusive stories.


Next Opponent

09/23/2022 TBD on ESPN networks
  • Rankings
  • Schedule
  • Results
  • Home
  • Roster
  • USMNT News
  • MLS
  • Americans Abroad
  • Alumni
  • USNSTPA
  • Archive

Klinsmann has to show his work

November 17, 2016 by Charles Boehm

usmnt coach jurgen klinsmann press conference soccer nov 2016

By Charles Boehm – WASHINGTON DC (Nov 17, 2016) US Soccer Players – The USMNT are 0-2 in the Hexagonal round of CONCACAF World Cup qualifying. They’re lodged in last place with a -5 goal differential after the first phase of matches. It appears that the knives are out for Jurgen Klinsmann. It’s not a nice place for any of us to be. How did we get here, and what lies ahead?

A skeptical subset of supporters and a few scattered voices in the media have called for a change for some time. Following two World Cup qualifying losses, they’ve got a lot of company. One major outlet after another has posted columns calling for Klinsmann’s departure in the wake of Tuesday’s 4-0 shelling in Costa Rica.

Even the posts analyzing the circumstances that might lead to a move are only marginally more neutral. They still put the prospect of a coaching change on the public’s mind. It’s not as if the idea is likely to fade away in the four months between now and the USMNT’s next World Cup qualifier.

Most of us know better than to think losing in November means disaster. There’s plenty of road in front of the USMNT on the way to the 2018 World Cup. The campaign is hardly doomed. The USMNT remains one of the most talented and experienced squads in the Hex. Public perception is where it is, but they’re still a favorite to advance. Still, something has changed.

It’s the manner and timing of these two defeats that has so many fingers perched on the panic button, of course. Klinsmann said that he wanted this rugged early schedule. For weeks, he played it up as a chance to make the Mexico and Costa Rica games a combined statement of intent. This is a region that the Yanks have dominated for quite some time now. The dark side of the two-headed challenge went unmentioned. Yet it’s upon us.

His bullishness wasn’t surprising. The promise of Klinsmann was a clear, cultured on-field playing identity. That hasn’t taken sustained shape. Instead, prominent and persistent optimism has become the defining element of the Klinsmann era. That quality undoubtedly played a huge role in his iconic achievements as a player. It’s also a useful one to have in his current line of work. A team needs pushing towards lofty achievements amid a great deal of noise and scrutiny. That’s the game at this level.

Klinsmann may eventually be undone by his recurring inability to tailor this character trait of his to the conditions at hand. Not every scenario is going to unfold in best-case fashion. Most of the countless other people who are invested in his team’s success are not interested in the contortions required to share his sunny worldview at the moment. Serious setbacks call for serious responses.

The man Goal.com dubbed “Coach Sunshine” in the first months of his tenure seems to have only belatedly realized the depth of the frustration and fear swirling around this poor start to the Hex. That’s not just about the past week. Those losses only reignited the doubts.

“A very, very bitter moment for us,” Klinsmann said at Estadio Nacional Tuesday night. “We didn’t imagine going into the hexagonal with two defeats right at the beginning. This is a moment to reflect [on] what happened the last 10 days. It’s not about blaming now any of the players. It’s about taking it, swallowing it, taking responsibility – which I do – and find a way to get that corrected.”

Yet even that long-overdue affirmation of direct personal accountability was immediately followed by a bizarrely jocular upturn.

“At the end of the day I said to the team that it won’t be the last 4-0 defeat in their career,” he continued. “They will get here and there some lessons. But definitely it’s a bitter moment because we wanted to do far, far better than what we did.”

I’ve been watching this program for more than two decades, first as a fan and then as a journalist. I can recall only a scant few performances as underwhelming as the one that led to that humbling handed out in San Jose. Fewer still carried the multiplier effect of coming close on the heels of an historic setback like Friday’s loss to Mexico in Columbus.

What’s alarming is not the score lines or even the dismaying details of how they unfolded. It’s the stubbornness. Maybe it’s just tone-deafness at this point. Regardless, Klinsmann clings to the status quo. The Costa Rica game presented differing challenges, and modified states of fitness and mindset among his squad. Yet he rolled out nearly an exact lineup from the one that started against Mexico, albeit in a 4-4-2 instead of a 3-5-2.

In retrospect Klinsmann’s moves were startling, perhaps definingly so. Playing an old rival in a traditional place of strength prompted him to wildly shuffle the deck tactically. Four days later, he responded to the program’s longest-standing nightmare destination (the US are now 0-9-1 in qualifiers at Costa Rica) by tossing out a same-old, same-old offering that Ticos manager Oscar Ramirez would have seen coming from miles away.

Afterwards I thought back to a subtle moment in the press conference after Friday’s 2-1 loss at Mapfre Stadium. The question was to explain two of his most prominent selection decisions, involving the central midfield and right back positions.

“If you see every training session – which you can’t, because we only let you go in for 15 minutes – you would get the confirmation,” Klinsmann said with a wan chuckle as he listed his justifications.

The man whose hiring was a new dawn of a more enlightened and transparent era was essentially asking us to take his word for it, despite a tangibly poor final result. I feel confident that no one in the USMNT press pack seriously thinks they know more about the game than Klinsmann or could do a better job than him. However, questions are part of the process, especially when things go south in match play.

The scoreboard tells us that he got his final answers wrong, and he hasn’t shown his work. Even an intro geometry teacher would struggle to give partial credit.


Charles Boehm is a Washington, DC-based writer and the editor of The Soccer Wire. Contact him at:cboehm@thesoccerwire.com. Follow him on Twitter at:http://twitter.com/cboehm.

More from Charles Boehm:

  • Pulisic, personnel, and politics
  • Preview: Big questions for USMNT vs Mexico
  • Will old results hold for USMNT vs Mexico?
  • Questions for USMNT players in the MLS playoffs
Like Google +1 1 Retweet 2

Filed Under: Featured, Soccer News, Top Posts, USMNT Tagged With: concacaf, jurgen klinsmann, us soccer, world cup qualifying

Plenty of teams are chasing the 2022 Supporters’ Shield

Plenty of teams are chasing the 2022 Supporters’ Shield

By Jason Davis

LAFC is currently at the top of the Supporters’ Shield table, but their lead over Austin FC is only two points with Eastern teams in the picture.

Below the 20 point line in MLS

Below the 20 point line in MLS

By J Hutcherson

Three teams in each conference have less than 20 points so far in the 2022 Major League Soccer season, but that may not tell us as much as it should.

Insigne at Toronto is a big move and a major statement

Insigne at Toronto is a big move and a major statement

By Jason Davis

Lorenzo Insigne joins Toronto FC with the Major League Soccer club in position to make a push in a tight Eastern Conference table.

More from our writers

US Soccer Players

Cameron Carter-Vickers

Cameron Carter-Vickers - USMNT

Position Defender
Pro Team Celtic
Read more about Cameron Carter-Vickers - USMNT

UNITED STATES NATIONAL SOCCER TEAM PLAYERS ASSOCIATION

Players

  • Squad
  • Results
  • Schedule
  • Match Reports

Soccer News

  • National Team
  • Major League Soccer
  • Americans Abroad
  • Featured

About USNSTPA

  • About US Soccer Players
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Sponsorship and Licensing

Copyright © 2022 All Rights Reserved - US Soccer Players.