US Soccer Players

The official site of the USMNT Soccer Players with soccer news, schedule, statistics, players, interviews, and exclusive stories.


Next Opponent

3/24/2023 8pm ET on TBD
  • Rankings
  • Schedule
  • Results
  • Home
  • Roster
  • USMNT News
  • MLS
  • Americans Abroad
  • Alumni
  • USNSTPA
  • Archive

MLS creates a David Villa issue

November 2, 2016 by Jason Davis

david villa nycfc referee 2016 mls season soccer

By Jason Davis – WASHINGTON, DC (Nov 2, 2016) US Soccer Players – Toronto FC’s 2-0 win over NYCFC on Sunday created a bit of controversy. It had nothing to do with Patrick Vieira’s decision to change his team’s long-standing attacking approach. It wasn’t his choice to swap out the starting goalkeeper for 33 of the club’s 34 regular season games for a backup with just one MLS game on his record.

Instead, the controversy that was the talk of MLS fans Monday and into Tuesday was the potential suspension of NYCFC star striker David Villa. It was his choice to kick out at TFC’s Armando Cooper in the 20th minute of the first-leg. Villa’s action was just one of a series of borderline violent moments in game marked by its physical intensity. There was a “coming together” of several players after the match. The anger visible on star striker Jozy Altidore’s face told the story about just how rough the match had been.

Obviously losing Villa to a suspension for the second leg would be a massive blow to NYCFC’s hopes. Villa finished second in MLS in goals this year with 23 and is a finalist for the league MVP award. Villa is, to wax poetically, the beating heart of a new club that needs both production and leadership from high profile positions like forward. Villa provides both, and in large quantities. He earns the $5.6 million City Football Group pays him to be one of the faces of their American investment.

So from that perspective, it’s good news that NYCFC won’t be without Villa on Sunday. Major League Soccer’s Disciplinary Committee decided not to hand down a suspension for Villa’s kick at Cooper, though the league did disclose that the group unanimously agreed that it was worthy of a red card in the moment. That’s problematic since referee Silvio Petrescu didn’t even call a foul. The contradiction inherent in the decision is, needless to say, causing some consternation among the MLS community. If Villa’s kick was bad enough to warrant a straight red, carrying with it a suspension, why didn’t the DisCo take the obvious action?

The cynical view is that Villa’s star power means leniency. Leagues need their stars on the field, not serving suspensions. MLS as a whole misses out if Villa doesn’t play. The larger organization whose mandate is to grow, grow, grow needs these moments. That Villa plays for a new team based in the country’s biggest media market owned by a ultra-wealthy group with interests on several continents only adds to the pressure to keep him eligible. At least that’s the perception.

Villa dodging a suspension serves NYCFC. It also serves the league from a publicity perspective. One prominent American soccer voice took to Twitter on Tuesday to identify who it doesn’t serve.

The @MLS Disciplinary Committee failed the players & coaches throughout the league because in its biggest moment it showed weakness. #Villa

— Taylor Twellman (@TaylorTwellman) November 2, 2016

Whether Villa’s kick out was violent enough in the moment to demand a decision by Petrescu is no longer germane to the discussion. The Disciplinary Committee declared it was via a unanimous vote. What is troubling is that they’re attempting to have it both ways. Bad enough for a red card, but not bad enough for a suspension. It’s a dodge, and an awkward one. Leaning on a strict reading of the words “egregious and reckless” in the language that guides their oversight only goes so far in letting them off the hook.

There’s a vast gray area in the officiating of a game involving grown adults happening at high speed. Petrescu was wrong. Or he wasn’t. He was “letting them play.” Or he failed to “control the game.” He decided Coopers high elbow cancelled out Villa’s kick, or he didn’t see either as he jogged through the center of the field toward the ball. Refereeing is quite often more art than science.

Using retroactive refereeing means all of that gray area has to be eliminated for those moments under review. If a committee of individuals is going to have the benefit of watching a sequence over and over again, in full-speed, half-speed, and super slo-mo, with a mandate to make decisions nominally meant to protect players and improve the quality of the league, any notions of leeway must be dismissed with prejudice.

It’s impossible to eliminate subjectivity from the process, but that should still be the goal.

With their half-this, half-that decision, MLS only prompted cries of preferential treatment. This does nothing to chip away at the kind of behavior Villa engaged in. That’s not just job not done, it’s a job done poorly.


Jason Davis is the founder of MatchFitUSA.com and the host of The United States of Soccer on SiriusXM. Contact him: matchfitusa@gmail.com. Follow him on Twitter:http://twitter.com/davisjsn.

More From Jason Davis:

  • Dropping the interim coaching tag in MLS
  • The USL picks up Tampa Bay and Ottawa at the NASL’s expense
  • Sunday is Decision Day for MLS
  • Playing for next season with a game left in MLS
Like 6 Google +1 1 Retweet 2

Filed Under: Featured, MLS, Soccer News Tagged With: 2016 MLS season, MLS Playoffs, nycfc, toronto fc

The rest of the 2022-23 season for USMNT players in Germany’s leagues

The rest of the 2022-23 season for USMNT players in Germany’s leagues

By Jason Davis

Jason Davis looks at the situations for clubs with USMNT players in Germany’s Bundesliga, 2.Bundesliga, 3.Liga, and Regionalliga West.

Defense, identity, and urgency from the USMNT vs Serbia

Defense, identity, and urgency from the USMNT vs Serbia

By Charles Boehm

Charles Boehm highlights the USMNT defense, tactical plan, urgency, and wide play during the 2-1 friendly loss to Serbia on January 25, 2023.

Plenty of tactical options for the USMNT vs Serbia

Plenty of tactical options for the USMNT vs Serbia

By Jason Davis

Jason Davis previews the USMNT vs Serbia friendly (10pm ET – HBO Max) with the focus on how the USMNT technical staff can use this squad.

More from our writers

US Soccer Players

reggie cannon usmnt player

Reggie Cannon - USMNT

Position Defender
Pro Team Boavista
Read more about Reggie Cannon - USMNT

UNITED STATES NATIONAL SOCCER TEAM PLAYERS ASSOCIATION

Players

  • Squad
  • Results
  • Schedule
  • Match Reports

Soccer News

  • National Team
  • Major League Soccer
  • Americans Abroad
  • Featured

About USNSTPA

  • About US Soccer Players
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Sponsorship and Licensing

Copyright © 2023 All Rights Reserved - US Soccer Players.