US Soccer Players

The official site of the USMNT Soccer Players with soccer news, schedule, statistics, players, interviews, and exclusive stories.


Next Opponent

3/24/2023 8pm ET on TBD
  • Rankings
  • Schedule
  • Results
  • Home
  • Roster
  • USMNT News
  • MLS
  • Americans Abroad
  • Alumni
  • USNSTPA
  • Archive

Are MLS stadiums built to last?

March 9, 2017 by J Hutcherson

mapfre-stadium-columbus-soccer-specific-stadium

By J Hutcherson (Mar 9, 2017) US Soccer Players – Everybody in pro sports wants to build their version of Dodgers Stadium. They want to get the location and design right to begin with, becoming an archetype for what’s best about where we play sports. There’s a reason waves of stadiums have come and gone since Dodger Stadium opened in 1962. At this point, stadium longevity is something few people expect.

Later this season, Atlanta United will share Mercedes-Benz Stadium with the Atlanta Falcons. Sizing the field area and the lower bowl “with soccer in mind” is now standard practice for National Football League stadiums. An earlier generation of stadiums makes it difficult to fit an appropriately sized field. With the number of lucrative games on offer every year in the United States, it doesn’t make sense to build a venue so it’s gridiron-specific.

In other words, that push for soccer-specificity is not the same issue it was when the Columbus Crew needed an alternative to a college football stadium. Things change, and that’s one of the problems for looking at any stadium as a decades-long answer. They just aren’t, at least not anymore.

MLS already has an issue with earlier generation venues not comparing well to the latest versions. In a press event at Philadelphia’s facility, commissioner Don Garber said in response to getting to a stadium without easy connections to public transportation, “It’s not necessarily a concern because if we didn’t have that facility, we wouldn’t be here in Philadelphia. This team has been able to be successful and do it in spite of the fact that there isn’t enough public transportation.”

Some leagues won’t settle for “in spite of” in the long term. National Hockey League commissioner Gary Bettmann is trying to help an effort to move the Phoenix Coyotes out of suburban Glendale. It’s no surprise that the major threat to a metropolitan area in that situation is to move the team to another city.

The NHL picked the wrong suburb, something that keeps leagues as well as families up nights when they’re planning their future. Their are enough dead and dying malls and aging developments to make anybody wonder what works over the long-term. Being able to forecast that is right up there with fortune telling.

FC Dallas is in a situation where they might have picked the wrong road. The Dallas Cowboys are building their mixed-use training center four miles south. Echoing Garber’s comments about Philadelphia, Dallas ending up where it is to keep the team in the area.

Chicago also went suburban shopping, ending up in Bridgeview as part of a larger development that never happened. The public transportation issues loom there as well in a new era where assuming people have cars simply doesn’t work anymore.

For most stadiums, a countdown begins as soon as they open. Eventually, there will be a significant overhaul costing significant money or a new pitch for an entirely new venue. That window of time when everything is fine in a nice new home grows shorter whenever anybody else gets something new.

It’s no different in MLS. Orlando City’s nice new home should have other teams looking around and seeing what they can remodel. The team as NFL tenant model was once the league’s greatest hurdle, but now it’s fine. The difference is MLS teams getting better deals to use venues they can’t build on their own. It certainly helps when they can draw big crowds to those big stadiums.

A team that built the 2000s-era panacea of a soccer-specific stadium is going to want something else. Others will follow. What we’ll see is another phase of North American soccer stadium construction following the established pattern. What was once great isn’t so much anymore. For the team to be able to prosper, it’s going to need to move somewhere else. Some would argue that we’re already seeing this happen.


J Hutcherson started covering soccer in 1999 and has worked as the general manager of the US National Soccer Team Players Association since 2002. Contact him at jhutcherson@usnstpa.com.

More from J Hutcherson:

  • Arsenal and that blame game
  • What haunts MLS?
  • San Diego’s MLS expansion bid is more than a stadium
  • Is the van Basten plan already over?
Like Google +1 1 Retweet 6

Filed Under: Featured, MLS, Soccer News, Top Posts Tagged With: soccer business

The rest of the 2022-23 season for USMNT players in Germany’s leagues

The rest of the 2022-23 season for USMNT players in Germany’s leagues

By Jason Davis

Jason Davis looks at the situations for clubs with USMNT players in Germany’s Bundesliga, 2.Bundesliga, 3.Liga, and Regionalliga West.

Defense, identity, and urgency from the USMNT vs Serbia

Defense, identity, and urgency from the USMNT vs Serbia

By Charles Boehm

Charles Boehm highlights the USMNT defense, tactical plan, urgency, and wide play during the 2-1 friendly loss to Serbia on January 25, 2023.

Plenty of tactical options for the USMNT vs Serbia

Plenty of tactical options for the USMNT vs Serbia

By Jason Davis

Jason Davis previews the USMNT vs Serbia friendly (10pm ET – HBO Max) with the focus on how the USMNT technical staff can use this squad.

More from our writers

US Soccer Players

reggie cannon usmnt player

Reggie Cannon - USMNT

Position Defender
Pro Team Boavista
Read more about Reggie Cannon - USMNT

UNITED STATES NATIONAL SOCCER TEAM PLAYERS ASSOCIATION

Players

  • Squad
  • Results
  • Schedule
  • Match Reports

Soccer News

  • National Team
  • Major League Soccer
  • Americans Abroad
  • Featured

About USNSTPA

  • About US Soccer Players
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Sponsorship and Licensing

Copyright © 2023 All Rights Reserved - US Soccer Players.