| Player | Club at the time | League at the time |
|---|---|---|
| Balboa, Marcelo | Club Leon | Liga MX |
| Berhalter, Gregg | PEC Zwolle | Eredivisie |
| Bliss, Brian | Carl Zeiss Jena | 2.Bundesliga |
| Burns, Mike | USMNT* | |
| Caligiuri, Paul | LA Salsa | APSL |
| Dooley, Thomas | Bayer Leverkusen | Bundesliga |
| Friedel, Brad | Brondby | Superliga |
| Harkes, John | Derby County | Premier League |
| Jones, Cobi | Coventry City | Premier League |
| Keller, Kasey | Millwall | Championship |
| Kerr, John | Millwall | Championship |
| Kirovski, Jovan | Manchester United | Premier League |
| Klopas, Frank | Apollon Athinon | Greece |
| Lalas, Alexi | Padova | Serie A |
| Lapper, Mike | VfL Wolfsburg | Bundesliga |
| Moore, Joe-Max | Saarbrucken | 2.Bundesliga |
| Ramos, Tab | Tigres | Liga MX |
| Reyna, Claudio | Bayer Leverkusen | Bundesliga |
| Sommer, Juergen | Luton Town | Championship |
| Sorber, Mike | UNAM Pumas | Liga MX |
| Stewart, Earnie | Willem II | Eredivsie |
| Wynalda, Eric | VfL Bochum | 2.Bundesliga |
