| Player | Club at the time | League at the time |
|---|---|---|
| Amrhein, Tom | Baltimore Canton | ASL |
| Czerkiewicz, Ed | Pawtucket Rangers | ASL |
| Dick, Walter | Pawtucket Rangers | ASL |
| Donelli, Aldo | Pittsburgh Curry Silver Tops | |
| Fielder, Bill | Philadelphia German-Americans | ASL |
| Florie, Tom | Pawtucket Rangers | ASL |
| Gallagher, Jimmy | Cleveland Slavia | |
| Gonsalves, Billy | Stix, Baer, and Fuller | St Louis Soccer League |
| Harker, Al | Philadelphia German-Americans | ASL |
| Hjulian, Julias | Chicago Wonderbolts | |
| Lehman, William | Stix, Baer, and Fuller | St Louis Soccer League |
| Lynch, Tom | Brooklyn Celtic | ASL |
| Martinelli, Joe | Pawtucket Rangers | ASL |
| McLean, Willie | Stix, Baer, and Fuller | St Louis Soccer League |
| Moorhouse, George | NY Americans | ASL |
| Nilsen, Werner | Stix, Baer, and Fuller | St Louis Soccer Leagye |
| Pietras, Peter | Philadelphia German-Americans | ASL |
| Rapp, Herman | Philadelphia German-Americans | ASL |
| Ryan, Francis | Philadelphia German-Americans | ASL |
