| Player | Club at the time | League at the time |
|---|---|---|
| Agoos, Jeff | DC United | MLS |
| Armas, Chris | Chicago | MLS |
| Brown, CJ | Chicago | MLS |
| Fraser, Robin | LA Galaxy | MLS |
| Friedel, Brad | Liverpool | Premier League |
| Jones, Cobi | LA Galaxy | MLS |
| Kirovski, Jovan | Borussia Dortmund | Bundesliga |
| Lewis, Eddie | San Jose | MLS |
| Llamosa, Carlos | DC United | MLS |
| McBride, Brian | Columbus | MLS |
| Meola, Tony | Kansas City | MLS |
| Olsen, Ben | DC United | MLS |
| Pop, Eddie | DC United | MLS |
| Razov, Ante | Chicago | MLS |
| Reyna, Claudio | Rangers | Premeirship |
| Vanney, Greg | LA Galaxy | MLS |
| Williams, Richie | DC United | MLS |
| Wynalda, Eric | Miami | MLS |
