| Player | Club at the time | League at the time |
|---|---|---|
| Beasley, DaMarcus | Chicago | MLS |
| Bocanegra, Carlos | Chicago | MLS |
| Brown, Aidan | New England | MLS |
| Califf, Danny | LA Galaxy | MLS |
| Convey, Bobby | DC United | MLS |
| Donovan, Landon | San Jose | MLS |
| Gibbs, Cory | St Pauli | Germany |
| Hejduk, Frank | Columbus | MLS |
| Keller, Kasey | Spurs | Premier League |
| Lewis, Eddie | PNE | First Division |
| Mastroeni, Pablo | Colorado | MLS |
| Mathis, Clint | MetroStars | MLS |
| McBride, Brian | Columbus | MLS |
| Mulrooney, Richard | San Jose | MLS |
| Ralston, Steve | New England | MLS |
| Reyna, Claudio | Sunderland | Premier League |
| Stewart, Earnie | DC United | MLS |
| Vanney, Greg | Bastia | France |
