| Player | Club at the time | League at the time |
|---|---|---|
| Albright, Chris | LA Galaxy | MLS |
| Beasley, DaMarcus | PSV | Eredivisie |
| Berhalter, Gregg | Energie Cottbus | 2.Bundesliga |
| Bocanegra, Carlos | Fulham | Premier League |
| Cherundolo, Steve | Hannover 96 | Bundesliga |
| Ching, Brian | Houston | MLS |
| Conrad, Jimmy | Kansas City | MLS |
| Convey, Bobby | Reading | Championship |
| Dempsey, Clint | New England | MLS |
| Donovan, Landon | LA Galaxy | MLS |
| Hahnemann, Marcus | Reading | Championship |
| Howard, Tim | Manchester United | Premier League |
| Johnson, Eddie | Kansas City | MLS |
| Keller, Kasey | Gladbach | Bundesliga |
| Lewis, Eddie | Leeds | Championship |
| Mastroeni, Pablo | Colorado | MLS |
| McBride, Brian | Fulham | Premier League |
| O’Brien, John | Chivas USA | MLS |
| Olsen, Ben | DC United | MLS |
| Onyewu, Oguchi | Standard Liege | Belgian Pro League |
| Pope, Eddie | Real Salt Lake | MLS |
| Reyna, Claudio | Manchester City | Premier League |
| Wolff, Josh | Kansas City | MLS |
